Asian Asbestos Conference 2009

Workshop 2: Medical Session

Moderator: Professors Domyung Paek and Naomi Hisanaga

Due to heavy consumption of asbestos during the twentieth century, the incidence of asbestos-related diseases in Japan is increasing. For victims to obtain financial relief for these diseases, it is essential that they receive an accurate diagnosis of their condition29. During the first presentation, Pathological Diagnosis of Asbestos-related Diseases, Professor Kouki Inai of Hiroshima University, having touched on the range of recognized diseases, concentrated his remarks on the continuing difficulties in making accurate diagnoses. Despite an array of tools such as clinical findings, laboratory data on serum or effusions and/or radiographic procedures including chest X-ray, CT or MRI scans30, uncertainties remained. The professor discussed research undertaken by his team into the diagnosis of asbestosis, diffuse pleural thickening and benign asbestos pleurisy using histopathological specimens, and explained the relevance of non-specific pathology and imaging findings. Although progress on diagnosing mesothelioma with techniques such as immunohistochemical analysis had been made, new diagnostic tools should be developed through molecular and genetic research. Judging from the Japanese experience, it was likely that the incidence of asbestos cancer would rise in other Asian countries in the near future.

An attempt to quantify the incidence of disease amongst ex-workers from an Indian asbestos factory, formerly called Hindustan Ferodo and later renamed Hindustan Composites Ltd. (HCL)31, was the subject of the presentation Asbestosis among ex-asbestos Workers of a Mumbai Asbestos Factory: A Prevalence Study, by Dr. Archana Kakade from the Mumbai Occupational Health and Safety Centre. A 2004 study of active HCL workers which found a low incidence of asbestosis in workers led researchers to postulate that the "healthy worker syndrome" had tainted the results32. To test out this hypothesis, a new study was undertaken among ex-HCL workers who had resigned, retired or been forced to resign under the government's Voluntary Retirement Scheme (VRS)33. Interviews were conducted, occupational histories were taken and the health of workers was accessed during phase 1 (April-June 2008) and phase 2 (July 2008-January 2009) of this project. The prevalence rate of asbestosis among ex- HCL workers in the recent study was 49%, as opposed to 23% in the 2004 cohort of active HCL workers.

Recognizing the multitude of problems faced by asbestosinjured workers in Mumbai, recommendations made by the speaker included: banning asbestos in India, the mandatory introduction of a national medical surveillance program for workers occupationally exposed to asbestos, occupational health training for doctors, the introduction of efficient industrial engineering controls, the reduction of allowable asbestos concentrations from 1 fiber/cc to 0.1 fiber/cc, the use of respiratory equipment and personal protective equipment, regular asbestos fiber monitoring, good housekeeping practices, and a program of asbestos education for all personnel.

High incidences of asbestos-related diseases have been found in Korean regions where asbestos fiber was mined, according to the presentation by Dr. Yeon-Soon Ahn of the Department of Occupational Medicine, Dongguk College, Goyang, Korea34. The results of an epidemiological survey undertaken by a team of Korean and Japanese researchers were detailed in the paper: Environmental Fallout from Asbestos Pollution in Korea - Asbestosis Epidemics from Neighborhood Exposure in Chungnam Province, Korea.

Due to para-occupational domestic and neighborhood exposures and exposure to naturally occurring asbestos, there was no difference in the prevalence rates of asbestosis and pleural plaques between miners and non-miners, i.e. members of the public who lived near the mines. This conclusion was the result of an epidemiological survey of 215 residents from five villages located within two kilometers of three asbestos mining sites. As a result of chest X-rays, 110 of the study subjects (51%) were suspected of having asbestos-related diseases; 95 were submitted for CT scans which established that 55 (64%) had asbestosis and 87 (92%) had pleural plaques35. Following up on the results of this work, the Korean Ministry of Environment was conducting an epidemiological survey of 10,000 residents who lived near 15 asbestos mines in Chungnam province. A Center for Asbestosis-related Environmental Disease had been established and a bill to provide assistance for environmental asbestos victims had been introduced.

Asbestos-related Lung Cancer among Japanese Construction Workers was the title of the talk given by Professor Naomi Hisanaga of the Aichi University of Education, Japan. Pictures shown of working practices during the 1980s backed up data which detailed incredibly high levels of asbestos exposure experienced by construction workers. Airborne asbestos concentrations exceeding 100 fibers/ml during the cutting of asbestos-containing boards using electric circular saws were not unusual. The researchers calculated that during 2005-2006 there was a total of 3,365 Japanese workers compensated by the government for mesothelioma and lung cancer, of which 1,387 (41%) worked in construction36; the second highest group affected were workers in shipbuilding who accounted for a total of 444 cases (13%).

Cutting operations resulted in exposure

Despite the acknowledged high-risk nature of construction work, many of the asbestos-injured from this industry did not qualify for compensation. Out of 34 lung-cancer patients whose details were recorded by the construction workers' health insurance society in Mie prefecture, 12 (35%) did not fulfill the criteria needed to obtain government compensation. Recognizing that construction workers remained on the asbestos front line, as evidenced by photographs showing hazardous working practices during current refurbishment work and demolition, the speaker concluded that current compensation requirements needed altering, so that all construction workers who suffered illness as a result of their occupational asbestos exposures obtained the benefits to which they were entitled. Regarding improved controls of hazardous exposures at current building sites promised by the government, the professor said that research on the carcinogenic potential of low-dose asbestos exposures was needed.

In the last 10-15 years, research on the treatment of mesothelioma had produced chemotherapy protocols for improving the duration and quality of life of mesothelioma patients, said Professor Bruce Robinson in his presentation: Latest Data on Mesothelioma Diagnosis and Treatment. Much of this work had been conducted in Australia, the country with the world's worst incidence of mesothelioma. Whereas the U.S., Europe and Japan had incidence rates of 15, 18 and 7 per million respectively, Australia's rate was 40 per million37. In Australia, mesothelioma was no longer restricted to occupational cohorts such as asbestos mine workers, boilermakers, insulators, dockers and construction workers, "mesothelioma is now a disease of 'the man in the street' - almost everyone has asbestos in their lungs."

Improvements had been made in diagnostic tools such as immunocytochemical staining, computed tomography imaging techniques, positron emission tomography (PET scanning) and the use of blood biomarkers (mesothelin)38 which, in some cases, had helped doctors make earlier diagnoses. Despite the progress, there was no cure for mesothelioma; front-line agents for treatment remained the use of a platinum agent plus an anti-metabolite such as pemetrexed and gemcitabine; new therapies featured the use of 2-drug combination chemotherapies with immunotherapy. Radical surgery was only recommended for selected cases and should be carried out in centers of excellence and in conjunction with adjuvant therapy. Gene therapy was still experimental.

The final presentation of the workshop reprised themes highlighted by speakers from Japan and Korea but placed them within an Australian context. Dr. Greg Deleuil, Medical Advisor to the Asbestos Diseases Society of Australia, spoke about Asbestosis in the Aftermath of Cyclone Tracy, a massive storm which struck Darwin, in Australia's Northern Territory, on December 24, 1974. In just 8 hours, winds of 270 km/h demolished most of the built environment leaving behind a city-sized asbestos-contaminated demolition site. The fact that most of the buildings in Darwin had been constructed of asbestos-containing building products meant that there were high levels of airborne asbestos in the aftermath of the cyclone. The speaker and his family who had lived in Darwin relocated to the city of Perth after the storm.

Photographs were shown which evidenced the destructive havoc wreaked by the cyclone; pictures of clean-up personnel wearing leather gloves, floppy hats and work boots showed them shoveling the debris or using heavy machinery to remove wreckage. The responders - personnel from the armed forces, day laborers and volunteers - had no breathing equipment or protective clothing. There were no health and safety regulations in place to minimize occupational exposures. In the last few months, the speaker had diagnosed two of the clean-up crew with asbestosis; there was no way to predict how many other emergency workers or Darwin residents would contract an asbestosrelated disease as a result of encountering Cyclone Tracy.

During the discussion phase of the workshop, the medical experts were asked technical questions about specimen preparation, ethics and techniques for screening patients, immunotherapy and the suitability of patients for radical surgery. There was a consensus that, as of then, no gold standard had been identified for treating mesothelioma patients.


29. According to Professor Inai, since 1948 Japanese victims with occupational asbestos exposures had been entitled to claim compensation from the government compensation scheme for asbestosis, benign asbestos pleurisy, diffuse pleural thickening, lung cancer and mesothelioma. Victims of non-occupational asbestos exposure who had contracted either lung cancer or mesothelioma had been able to claim compensation from a Japanese Relief System since 2006.
30. CT: computerized tomography; MRI: magnetic resonance imaging.
31. At the HCL factory, a range of asbestos products was manufactured including: clutch plates, brake liners, railway brake blocks, ropes, yarn, cloth and sheets. Workers, all of whom were ignorant about the asbestos health hazard, handled the fiber with no regard for the consequences; they used to play with balls of asbestos. The company management did not implement control measures to minimize occupational exposures; mandatory periodic medicals were not carried out.
32. The "healthy worker syndrome" came about because individuals who were too ill to work either resigned their jobs or died, leaving only the healthy workers to take part in the research.
33. Under the VRS, companies are able to off-load workers by giving them a package or incentive to take premature retirement, often using coercion to force them to accept the conditions on offer.
34. There are numerous talc and asbestos ore deposits in Chungnam. Of the 30+ asbestos mines in the Province, the Kwangcheon chrysotile asbestos mine was the biggest in Asia and had 1,000 workers. As a consequence of asbestos operations and the presence of naturally occurring asbestos, the levels of neighborhood exposure to serpentine and amphibole (mainly tremolite) asbestos in this area were elevated.
35. Of the 95 study subjects, nine cases of asbestosis were impossible to diagnose due to the poor quality of the scans.
36. According to a survey conducted in the Mie prefecture, the standardized proportional mortality ratio for construction workers for stomach cancer is 2.0 and for lung cancer 1.9.
37. Predicted cumulative deaths over the next 40 years are: 72,000 in the U.S., 250,000 in Europe, 103,000 in Japan and 30,000 in Australia.
38. According to the speaker, serum mesothelin (also known as serummesothelin- related protein or SMRP) is "the most sensitive and specific test. SMRP is elevated in over half the patients at diagnosis, and in around 75% of patients at some stage in their illness…elevated mesothelin/SMRP levels in the pleural fluid are also useful in diagnosis."